Sign-in Changes | VA Identity Flows | Terms of use accessibility | Observer meta-research | Experience research
VA.gov Identity | Sign-in changes
Objective: Move +1 million people from outdated, less secure sign-in methods by iteratively increasing the urgency of moving to a modern sign-in account, before deprecated accounts are removed. This change reduces agency burden and user confusion.
My Role: I led this iterative research and design work as UX lead of a product team on a federal contract. I led and conducted a substantial portion of the UX work, but I worked along side a UX researcher, a content designer, several engineers, and a product manager on my team. My team and I closely consulted with many VA and external stakeholders. Each iteration of our product complied with the VA Design System and accessibility guidelines from WCAG and 508.
Sign-in page, deprecation note state, live page
Four sign in options
Research, conducted by me and by other’s, continued to show Veteran frustration and confused by having so many options to sign in. The two older style accounts were potential security risks because they didn’t comply with latest NIST guidelines. Those same two sign-in account had fewer veterans using them. Stakeholder approved this work based on the qualitative research, quantitative metrics, and security concerns. The VA asked my team to move quickly.
A major effort
This was a herculean, multi-team effort. My team’s effort focused on iterating the sign-in page. I added iterative nudges to get folks to change to the modern, secure options. On the content side, using plain language wasn’t enough. My research found words and phrases around sign in that veterans found confusing. My design work incorporated that, and I worked closely with communication and marketing teams to keep wording aligned across channels. I worked with external partners who would be affected by these changes. I also went above and beyond and let my sign-in expertise during in-person registration events hosted by another team.
Sign-in page, visual deprecation state, live page
Figma designs showing two of the interstitials
Sign-in page changes
I designed changes to the sign-in page to give visual preference to the modern accounts. Over 70% of authentications were already being made with one one of these accounts. But we still had 2 million authentications each month from deprecated accounts. Those came from over a million users. That’s a lot of people’s who needed to change their sign in habits!
Usability research showed that adding an interstitial would help, especially those who already had a modern account but weren’t using it. We also uncovered information to help plan when to make our nudges more forceful.
Goals met
It looks like a long and iterative process to simply remove two buttons. But changing the habits of a million people takes time. It was important to first communicate changes and nudge the early adopters. It was important to use more forceful nudges, after some time, well ahead of button removal. Research showed that a large group of folks will wait until the last minute. Our goal was to move as many as we could, as early as possible.
Along the way I conduced several rounds of research, worked across stakeholders and teams to make a thoughtful set of designs that would nudge folks with increased urgency.
Throughout the process I kept a close eye on metrics. It was important to watch total usage and how many veterans were signing up with new accounts. As veterans stopped using the old options, the modern accounts saw an equal increase in use. This gave us confidence that we were successfully moving people over an not just cutting them off.
Sign-in page, post DS Logon removal state, live page
MHV sign-in usage mapped through front-end iterations